Comparing SMSFs with Other Super Funds: What You Need to Know

An SMSF gives you control of your super, but you become the trustee and carry the legal duties, the yearly audit and the fixed costs. How it compares with retail, industry and other funds, the costs and rules that apply in 2026–27, and how to compare the big funds.

Comparing SMSFs with Other Super Funds: What You Need to Know

Most Australians hold their super in a large fund run by a professional trustee – a retail, industry, public sector or corporate fund regulated by APRA. A self-managed super fund (SMSF) is the alternative: a fund of up to 6 members who are all its trustees, regulated by the ATO. An SMSF gives you control over what the fund invests in. In exchange you take on the trustee's legal duties, a compulsory independent audit every year and fixed running costs that don't shrink with your balance.

Large funds

A professional trustee runs the fund. You choose an investment option and the fund does the rest. Fees are mostly a percentage of your balance.

SMSF

You and up to 5 others are the trustees. You choose the investments and are legally responsible for the fund. Costs are largely fixed.

Who regulates

APRA regulates the large funds. The ATO regulates SMSFs and charges them an annual supervisory levy of $259, paid in the fund's tax return.

Weighing up an SMSF? We set them up – from $1,045 including GST with individual trustees, or $2,545 with a company trustee, trust deed included – then prepare the accounts and tax return each year. See SMSF setup and management and our independent SMSF audit.

The main types of super fund

  • Retail funds are run by banks, investment companies and other financial institutions. Anyone can join, and fees range from low to high.
  • Industry funds were set up for workers in particular industries. Many are now open to anyone.
  • Public sector funds are for government employees. Some long-standing members still hold defined benefit accounts.
  • Corporate funds are run by or for a single employer for its staff.
  • SMSFs are private funds of up to 6 members, who run the fund themselves as its trustees.

Comparing the large funds

If you are comparing retail and industry funds, start with the ATO's free YourSuper comparison tool. It ranks MySuper products – the default options most employers pay into – by net returns, using data from APRA. It shows the total annual fee, the investment strategy and net returns over 3, 5 and 10 years, and lets you compare up to 4 products side by side. Signed in through myGov, it also shows your own accounts next to the others.

Other things worth comparing:

  • Fees in dollars, not just percentages, at your balance.
  • Long-term net returns for the investment option you would actually use.
  • Insurance – the cover you get by default, its cost, and whether you would lose it by moving.
  • Investment choice – some funds let you pick individual shares or term deposits through a direct investment option.
  • Service – online access, advice and how claims are handled.

Before you move, check what happens to insurance in your current fund, and consolidate other accounts so you don't pay two sets of fees.

SMSF vs large fund, side by side

SMSFRetail or industry fund
Who decides the investmentsYou, as trusteeThe fund; you choose an option
MembersUp to 6, all trusteesThousands or millions
Legal responsibilityYouThe professional trustee
RegulatorATOAPRA (and ASIC)
CostsMostly fixed: accounts, tax return, audit, $259 ATO levy, investment costsMostly a percentage of your balance, plus fixed admin fees
Annual auditRequired, by an independent ASIC-registered SMSF auditorDone at fund level
Investment choiceDirect property, shares, term deposits, unlisted assets and more, within the law and your investment strategyThe fund's menu of options
InsuranceArranged by the trusteesUsually default cover included
Fraud or theftNo government financial assistanceMembers may be eligible for government financial assistance

What an SMSF costs

An SMSF's running costs are mostly fixed, so as a percentage they fall as the balance grows and weigh heavily on a small fund. Expect to pay for:

  • Set-up – the trust deed, a company trustee if you choose one, and registration.
  • Annual accounts and the SMSF annual return.
  • The independent audit every year.
  • The ATO supervisory levy – $259 a year, paid in the fund's tax return (the SMSF annual return). A new fund pays $518 with its first annual return: the levy for the year it was set up and the following year.
  • Investment costs – brokerage, platforms, valuations, and insurance if the fund holds it.

When does an SMSF break even on cost? As a rough guide, an SMSF with a balance of around $200,000 can be cost-competitive with a large fund – the figure most often quoted, from industry research by Rice Warner for the SMSF Association (2020). Treat it as approximate: it depends on what the fund invests in and how much of the work the trustees do themselves. As the research was done in 2020, the figure may have changed. Whatever your balance, you must make your own decision whether to set one up or not.

At BTMH, SMSF set-up is $1,045 including GST with individual trustees or $2,545 with a company trustee (trust deed and government charges included), and an SMSF audit starts from $363. Accounts and the tax return are quoted per fund, because the work depends on what the fund holds.

What being a trustee involves

Every member of an SMSF is a trustee (or a director of the company trustee), and each one is legally responsible for the fund – even if another member makes the decisions. Trustees must:

  • sign the ATO trustee declaration within 21 days of becoming a trustee
  • run the fund for the sole purpose of providing retirement benefits – no personal benefit now, such as using a fund holiday house or lending fund money to a member or relative
  • prepare, follow and regularly review a written investment strategy that considers diversification, liquidity, risk and whether to hold insurance for members
  • keep the fund's assets separate from their own and in the fund's name, and deal with related parties only on an arm's length, commercial basis
  • not lend to members or borrow, except within the narrow exceptions the law allows – and since 10 August 2026 an SMSF can no longer borrow to buy residential property
  • keep records, minutes and the trustee declaration for at least 10 years
  • have the fund audited every year and lodge the SMSF annual return

Breaches can mean penalties for the trustees personally and, in serious cases, the fund being made non-complying and taxed at the top rate.

What an SMSF can't do

The fund's money is for retirement, not for propping up anything you own now. In particular, an SMSF:

  • can't be used to fund your own business. Loans to, investments in and leases to members, relatives and businesses they control ("in-house assets") are capped at 5% of the fund's assets. Leasing business real property to your business at market rent is the main exception.
  • can't buy assets from you or your relatives, with a few exceptions – mainly listed shares and business real property bought at market value.
  • can't let you, your family or other related parties live in or holiday in a residential property it owns, or rent it to them.
  • must keep its assets apart from yours – in the fund's name, in its own bank account, never mixed with personal or business money.

The annual independent audit

Every SMSF must be audited each year by an independent SMSF auditor registered with ASIC, before the annual return is lodged. The auditor checks the financial statements and whether the fund has complied with super law, and must report certain breaches to the ATO. The auditor must be independent of the fund and its trustees, so the firm that prepares your accounts generally can't also audit them.

What changed in 2026

Borrowing for residential property. An SMSF can no longer borrow to buy residential property under a contract signed on or after 10 August 2026. Existing loans are not affected, and borrowing for business property is still allowed. We cover the detail in Buying a house through your super? The rules just changed.

Division 296 tax on large balances. The Division 296 tax is now law and applies from 1 July 2026 (the 2026–27 year). It is assessed to the individual, not the fund, and applies whether your super is in an SMSF or a large fund:

  • an extra 15% on the share of your fund's earnings linked to your balance above $3 million
  • a further 10% on the share linked to your balance above $10 million

Both thresholds are indexed to inflation. SMSFs will report members' super earnings in the annual return from 2026–27, an SMSF can elect to reset the cost base of its CGT assets to market value at 30 June 2026, and the ATO expects to issue the first assessments in the second half of 2027–28. If your balance is anywhere near $3 million, talk to us before 30 June 2027.

When an SMSF tends to suit – and when it doesn't

The common reasons people set up an SMSF:

  • To hold a specific investment that a large fund won't offer – such as a particular asset or unlisted investment you have chosen.
  • To buy property. Often the premises your own business operates from (business real property, which the fund can lease to your business at market rent), or an investment property held for the long term. The fund has to pay for residential property from its own money: it can no longer borrow for it.
  • To run your own investment portfolio – direct shares, ETFs and cash, chosen and managed by you rather than a fund's investment menu.
  • To bring family super together – up to 6 members, often a couple and their adult children, sharing one set of costs.

People who run SMSFs well usually have:

  • a balance large enough for fixed costs to be a small share of it
  • the time and interest to make investment decisions and keep records every year
  • a reason to want control – for example to hold the business premises the family business operates from, or a particular mix of direct shares
  • fellow members they trust, often a spouse or adult children, because every trustee carries the responsibility for the others' decisions

It is usually a poor fit if your balance is small, you want someone else to handle everything, you rely on your fund's default insurance, or members are likely to disagree.

Whether an SMSF is right for you is a financial product decision, and the law requires that personal advice on it come from a licensed financial adviser. We explain how SMSFs work, set them up, keep them compliant and audit them – and we are happy to work alongside your adviser.

Common questions

How many members can an SMSF have?

Up to 6. Every member must be a trustee, or a director of the company that is the trustee.

What is the SMSF supervisory levy?

$259 a year, paid to the ATO with the SMSF annual return. A new fund pays $518 with its first return, covering the year it was set up and the following year.

Does an SMSF need an audit every year?

Yes. An independent SMSF auditor registered with ASIC must audit the fund every year before the annual return is lodged.

Can my SMSF still buy a residential property?

Yes, but from 10 August 2026 it can't borrow to do it. See the new SMSF property borrowing rules.

Is the Division 296 tax law?

Yes. It applies from 1 July 2026 to people whose total super balance is over $3 million, with a higher rate on the part over $10 million.

How do I close an SMSF?

The trustees roll over or pay out every member's benefits, sell or transfer the assets, have the final year audited and lodge a final annual return. See how to wind up an SMSF.

How do I compare super funds?

For retail and industry funds, use the ATO's YourSuper comparison tool to compare MySuper products on fees and net returns, then check insurance and investment options. For an SMSF, compare the total yearly cost in dollars with what you pay now.

How we can help

If you are thinking about an SMSF, we can explain the set-up, the costs and the trustee duties, and run the fund's accounts, tax return and compliance once it exists. Our separate SMSF audit service audits funds anywhere in Australia. See SMSF setup and management, get in touch or call (02) 9386 0500.

Related reading

How to Wind Up an SMSF: Closing a Self-Managed Super Fund Step by Step

Nominate Your Tax Agent: Why the ATO Asks You to Link Your Company to Your Accountant

ABN vs ACN: what's the difference?